LONDON: When US counterterrorism researchers investigated how extremists were exploiting Telegram, they published a report with a name that captured the darker side of the messaging app: “Terrorgram.” On Monday, Telegram was banned in both Jordan and Iraq, highlighting the challenges governments face in balancing digital privacy and freedom of expression against the threat of online extremism. Jordan’s ban follows the Oct. 23 attack on a church that killed nine people and injured more than 30 — an act of terrorism that drew international condemnation. Although no details of how the attackers communicated have been released, and the ban has not been officially linked to the attack, Jordan’s security directorate said Telegram was being blocked as part of “efforts aiming to bolster digital security” and counter “attempts to spread radicalization and extremism which affect national security.” The ban came a day after a Jordanian court sentenced three men to death for the attack. Also on Monday, Iraq’s Communications and Media Commission announced it was banning Telegram to curb the “exploitation of social media platforms to spread radical speech, incite sedition, violence and hatred.” In a statement, the commission said: “The operating company failed to take the necessary measures to address non-compliant content published on the platform and did not adhere to Iraqi laws.” It gave the company 30 days to comply with regulatory requirements. Despite their timing, the two bans do not appear to be connected. A Telegram spokesperson told Arab News: “Telegram’s extensive efforts to combat terrorism are publicly documented and go far beyond legal requirements to protect its billion-plus users. “Advanced automated systems and moderators empowered with AI tools proactively monitor public parts of the platform to systematically remove terrorist content.” There was, the spokesperson added, “no evidence linking Telegram to the church attack. Many articles have included this detail without noting there is no link and readers are being misled.” On Monday, Arab News’ sister newspaper, Asharq Al-Awsat, reported that Iraq’s ban came amid a “worsening confrontation” between Prime Minister Ali Al-Zaidi and Kataib Hezbollah, an Iran-backed armed faction, “whose affiliates are among Telegram’s most active users in Iraq, where the app is widely used by government institutions, media outlets and armed groups.” It is not the first time Telegram has been blocked in Iraq. Authorities imposed a temporary, unannounced ban on national security grounds following the outbreak of the US-Israeli war with Iran in February. A 2024 paper by the Center for Economic Research in Pakistan (CERP) identified the dilemma at the heart of attempts to regulate Telegram. Writing in the Pakistan Journal of Terrorism Research, CERP said Telegram “has long stood by its commitment to user privacy, emphasizing that its goal of protecting freedom of speech and privacy outweighs all other considerations. “In some cases, this has empowered citizens to mobilize against oppressive regimes and operate amid rising tensions. “However, the very chat rooms that were meant to help users have an easier life have been misused by individuals who spread extremist, criminal, and terrorist ideologies.” To address the problem, the researchers argued, “a comprehensive regulatory framework needs to be established that helps balance privacy rights with its security implications.” Extremists of various ideological backgrounds have been drawn to Telegram’s combination of mass communication capabilities and privacy protections. In a 2020 report, the United Nations Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICRI) identified Telegram as a key channel through which “terrorist, violent extremist and organized criminal groups are trying to take advantage of the Coronavirus disease pandemic to expand their activities and jeopardize the efficacy and credibility of response measures by governments.”
También lo cubren: arabnews.com - Arab News, arabnews.com - Arab News (Arabia Saudí), arabnews.pk - Arab News Pakistan, arabnews.pk - Arab News Pakistan (Arabia Saudí).
Ver más en NewsToday